Choosing the right monthly subscription box for your dog can be challenging, especially when comparing top contenders like Bullymake and BarkBox. Each service offers unique benefits, but which one truly delivers the best value for your furry friend? This comprehensive guide breaks down everything you need to know about Bullymake vs BarkBox to help you make an informed decision.
Whether you have a gentle nibbler or an aggressive chewer, understanding the key differences between these popular subscription services is crucial. Let's explore their offerings, pricing, durability, and special features to help you choose the perfect box for your pup.
Core Offerings and Box Contents
BarkBox's standard subscription includes two toys, two bags of all-natural treats, and one chew per month. Their Super Chewer option upgrades to two tough toys and two chews, designed for more aggressive chewers. They also offer specialized services like the Bark Bright dental kit and Bark Eats pre-portioned food.
Bullymake focuses exclusively on durability, providing 2-3 tough toys and three treats in their standard box. They uniquely offer a toy-only option with 4-5 toys, perfect for owners who prefer to source treats separately or have dogs with dietary restrictions.
Pricing and Value Comparison
BarkBox generally maintains lower price points across their subscription options, including their Super Chewer tier. They frequently offer multi-box discounts, though these often come with minimum commitment terms.
Bullymake positions itself as a premium option with higher pricing, justified by their focus on ultra-durable toys. While annual subscriptions can offer up to 20% savings, their month-to-month rates tend to be higher than competitors.
Durability and Dog Size Considerations
BarkBox's standard subscription works well for average chewers, while their Super Chewer line offers enhanced durability. However, even their tougher options prioritize variety and engagement over maximum durability.
Bullymake specializes in extra-tough toys designed for power chewers and larger breeds. Their toys are crafted from materials like tough nylon, ballistic nylon, and robust rubber, specifically engineered to withstand aggressive chewing.
Customization Options
Both services accommodate common allergies and dietary restrictions. BarkBox offers additional customization through customer service, allowing specific toy or treat preferences. Bullymake lets subscribers choose preferred toy materials and offers the unique toy-only subscription option.
Quality Assurance and Guarantees
Bullymake stands out with their straightforward replacement policy: if a toy is destroyed, simply submit a photo within 14 days for a replacement. BarkBox offers a satisfaction guarantee but with less specific terms regarding replacements.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which dog subscription box is better for heavy chewers, Bullymake or BarkBox Super Chewer?
Bullymake is generally considered superior for heavy chewers, offering more durable toys specifically designed for aggressive chewers. While BarkBox's Super Chewer option is tougher than their standard box, it may not match Bullymake's durability level for extreme chewers.
How do the prices and subscription plans of Bullymake compare to BarkBox?
BarkBox typically offers lower prices across all subscription tiers. Bullymake is more expensive but provides specialized durability-focused products. Both services offer discounts on longer-term commitments, with BarkBox generally remaining the more economical choice.
Can I customize toy materials and treats in Bullymake and BarkBox boxes for my dog's allergies?
Yes, both services accommodate allergies and dietary restrictions. Bullymake allows specific toy material preferences (nylon, rubber, rope, or ballistic), while BarkBox can customize treats and toys through customer service requests.
What are the differences in toy durability and safety between Bullymake and BarkBox?
Bullymake focuses on maximum durability with tough materials like nylon and ballistic fabric. BarkBox, even in their Super Chewer line, balances durability with variety and engagement. Some Bullymake toys may be too hard for certain dogs, so consult your veterinarian about safety.
How does Bullymake's toy replacement guarantee compare to BarkBox's satisfaction policy?
Bullymake offers a clear, straightforward replacement guarantee: if a toy is destroyed, submit a photo within 14 days for a replacement. BarkBox's satisfaction guarantee is less specific and may require more interaction with customer service for resolutions.
Conclusion
When choosing between Bullymake vs BarkBox, consider your dog's chewing habits and size. BarkBox offers better value for average chewers and smaller dogs, with more variety and lower prices. Bullymake excels for power chewers and large breeds, providing maximum durability despite higher costs.
Ultimately, both services deliver quality products with strong customer support. Your choice should align with your dog's specific needs and your budget preferences.
