Understanding the Drawbacks of Owning a Nova Scotia Duck Tolling Retriever
The Nova Scotia Duck Tolling Retriever, affectionately known as the Toller, is a lively and intelligent breed originally developed to lure and retrieve waterfowl. While their charm, energy, and loyalty make them a favorite among active dog enthusiasts, it’s important to understand the potential cons of owning a Toller before bringing one into your home. This article explores the challenges that may arise and helps prospective owners make informed decisions.
1. High Energy Levels Require Intense Commitment
Tollers have exceptionally high energy and thrive on physical activity and mental stimulation. Without at least one hour of dedicated daily exercise—such as long walks, playtime, or engaging sports—these dogs can develop undesirable behaviors.
- Problem behaviors may include destructiveness, restlessness, or excessive barking.
- Not suited for owners with sedentary lifestyles or limited mobility.
Potential owners must be ready to integrate vigorous activity into their daily routine consistently.
2. Prone to Separation Anxiety
Tollers form strong bonds with their families and are not well-suited to long periods of isolation. Leaving them alone frequently can result in anxiety-driven behaviors.
- They may bark incessantly, become destructive, or even injure themselves out of boredom or stress.
- This breed thrives in households where at least one member is home regularly.
3. Intense Shedding and Grooming Requirements
The Toller’s double coat is beautiful but demands upkeep. It undergoes heavy seasonal shedding and needs brushing multiple times a week—daily during molting periods.
- Regular brushing helps avoid matting and controls fur around the house.
- Requires ear checks, nail trims, and occasional baths for optimal health.
4. Can Be Too Boisterous for Young Children
While generally good with respectful children, Tollers can be overly exuberant for toddlers.
- Their playful energy may unintentionally knock small kids over.
- Early supervision and teaching kids proper dog interaction is essential.
5. Prey Drive Requires Supervision Around Small Animals
Tollers retain a strong prey drive due to their hunting background. While they may live peacefully with cats they were raised alongside, new small pets may be seen as chase-worthy.
- Supervision and gradual introductions are critical when incorporating other animals into the household.
- They may not be reliable around rabbits, rodents, or unfamiliar cats.
6. Strong-Willed and Easily Bored
Though highly intelligent, Tollers are known to be independent thinkers. They resist repetitive training methods and may tune out if learning isn’t fun or engaging.
- Requires patient, positive-reinforcement training.
- Frequent mental challenges are essential to keep them focused and fulfilled.
7. Inherited Health Issues
While generally hardy, Tollers are susceptible to some genetic conditions. Common health issues include:
- Hip and elbow dysplasia
- Progressive retinal atrophy (PRA)
- Collie eye anomaly
- Addison’s disease
- Deafness and cleft palates
Responsible breeders conduct health testing to reduce risks, but owners should be prepared for potential veterinary expenses.
8. Vocalization – The Toller Scream
Unique to the breed is the infamous “Toller scream”—a piercing, high-pitched yelp emitted when excited. Though some owners learn to tolerate it, for others, it can be startling or unwelcome in quiet household settings.
- This vocal trait is not easily trainable out of the dog.
- May be problematic in apartments or noise-sensitive environments.
9. Rarity and Cost
Tollers remain a relatively rare breed outside of North America. Acquiring a well-bred puppy may involve long wait lists, significant travel, and a hefty purchase price.
- Ongoing costs include grooming, training, dietary needs, and veterinary care.
- Finding breed-specific resources or veterinary expertise may be more difficult than with common breeds.
10. Not Ideal for First-Time Dog Owners
Due to their unique combination of needs and temperament traits, Tollers are better matched with experienced dog owners who understand behavior, training, and breed-specific care.
- New owners may struggle with managing energy, vocal behavior, or health maintenance.
- The breed thrives in environments where consistency, exercise, and mental engagement are prioritized.
Conclusion
Owning a Nova Scotia Duck Tolling Retriever is a rewarding experience for those with the time, energy, and experience to match. While their affectionate nature, intelligence, and agility are major draws, potential owners must prepare for the breed’s demands. Awareness of these potential drawbacks ensures informed decision-making and contributes to a lifelong, enriching partnership with one of Canada’s most unique sporting breeds.
