Comparing the Cost: Pitbull vs American Bully
When choosing a canine companion, it's important not only to consider a breed's temperament and physical characteristics but also the total cost of ownership. Two popular breeds that are often compared are the American Pit Bull Terrier (APBT) and the American Bully. While they may look similar to the untrained eye, their breed backgrounds, temperaments, and typical pricing reveal significant differences.
Breed Origins and Purpose
- American Pit Bull Terrier: Bred in 19th-century England by crossing Bulldogs with Terriers for strength and agility, often used in farm work and companionship.
- American Bully: Developed in the 1990s in the U.S. by mixing APBTs with American Staffordshire Terriers and other bulldog breeds to create a gentle, companion-focused dog.
This difference in origin leads to differences in market availability, breed standards, and ultimately price.
Physical Build and Popularity
American Bullies come in several size categories — Pocket, Standard, Classic, and XL — lending to more breed options and a broader price range. They are generally stockier and more muscular than Pit Bulls, with broader heads and shorter legs. Pit Bulls, by contrast, are leaner and more agile, typically used in various dog sports and work roles.
This muscular, stout appearance of Bullies makes them particularly desirable in show circuits and among breed enthusiasts, which plays into their pricing.
Temperament Drives Demand
American Bullies were intentionally bred for a more relaxed and tolerant personality. They’re renowned for being gentle giants — an ideal trait for families. This temperament consistency, combined with their strong appearance, has made them increasingly desirable — and expensive — in the pet trade. Pit Bulls, though loyal and affectionate when well-socialized, may display higher energy levels and potential reactivity if not adequately trained, limiting their demand among casual dog owners.
Cost Comparison
Pricing varies regionally and depends heavily on lineage, breeder reputation, and dog characteristics (age, pedigree, size). However, typical averages show:
- American Pit Bull Terrier: $500 – $1,200 depending on pedigree and breeder.
- American Bully: $2,000 – $10,000+, especially for rare bloodlines or XL varieties bred for show.
This significant price gap reflects both increased demand and breeding complexity associated with American Bullies. Specialized breeding programs focus on health, temperament, and conformation, which raise breeder costs and, by extension, buyer prices.
Additional Ownership Costs
Beyond initial purchase, all breeds entail ongoing expenses — food, medical care, training, and grooming. However, due to their size, XL Bullies can incur higher costs for food and veterinary needs compared to medium-sized Pit Bulls. Additionally, insurance and housing restrictions may also vary based on perceived breed risks, with Pit Bulls more frequently targeted by breed-specific legislation.
Conclusion
When comparing the American Bully and the Pit Bull in terms of cost, it’s clear that the American Bully generally commands a higher price on the market. This is influenced by its newer development, desirable temperament traits, show pedigree, and increased breeder investment. Nevertheless, both dogs make loyal and affectionate companions when raised with love, consistency, and structure.
