Disadvantages of Owning a Dutch Shepherd: What to Consider
The Dutch Shepherd is a remarkable breed recognized for its intelligence, loyalty, and athleticism. However, despite its many strengths, this herding dog may not be ideal for everyone. Below, we examine some of the most important cons of a Dutch Shepherd to help you decide if this breed is the right fit for your household.
1. High Energy Levels
One of the primary challenges of owning a Dutch Shepherd is its intense energy requirements. These dogs were bred to perform demanding tasks on farms, meaning they have exceptional stamina and drive.
- Require several hours of physical activity daily
- Need structured mental stimulation to stay balanced
- Prone to behavior problems if not adequately exercised
2. Not Ideal for First-Time Dog Owners
The breed’s independent thinking and drive make it more suited for experienced dog handlers. Without proper guidance:
- They might become stubborn or difficult to manage
- Training efforts may stall without consistent positive reinforcement
- Overstimulation or undertraining can lead to anxiety or aggression
3. Strong Herding Instinct
The natural herding instincts of Dutch Shepherds can manifest in household settings where they attempt to herd children, pets, or even adults—sometimes inappropriately.
- Herding tendencies may include nipping or circling
- Requires early and consistent training to manage instincts
- May not be the best choice for homes with small children
4. Can Be Reserved Toward Strangers
Despite their loyalty to family, Dutch Shepherds can be wary and cautious with strangers.
- Requires thorough socialization to avoid fear-based behaviors
- May become overprotective without the right exposure
- Bond deeply with family but may not be friendly with guests
5. Prone to Boredom-Related Destructiveness
If Dutch Shepherds are left alone for extended periods or lack stimulating tasks, they may become destructive or vocal:
- Couch chewing, digging, and inappropriate barking are common signs
- May develop separation anxiety or compulsive behaviors
- Needs a job to do—whether it’s agility, scent work, or play
6. Grooming Maintenance Varies
Though generally not excessive, the coat types of Dutch Shepherds differ in grooming needs:
- Short-haired types need occasional combing but daily brushing during shedding seasons
- Long-haired dogs need weekly bathing and detangling
- Rough-haired dogs require biannual hand-stripping to maintain healthy coat texture
7. Health Considerations
Although relatively healthy, some genetic conditions have been observed in the breed:
- Hip and elbow dysplasia
- Progressive retinal atrophy (in rough-haired types)
- Degenerative myelopathy or inflammatory myopathy in certain lines
- von Willebrand disease, especially in long-haired types
Responsible breeding practices help reduce the risk, but annual health checkups and genetic screening are recommended.
8. Need for an Active Lifestyle
Dutch Shepherds are not content lounging around all day. They need owners who:
- Participate in dog sports, hiking, or active playtime
- Have time and energy for training sessions
- Can commit to regular routines and physical engagement
Conclusion
While the Dutch Shepherd can be a loyal, skilled, and affectionate canine companion, they are best suited to households that understand and can meet their extensive physical and mental demands. For those ready to invest time and energy, the rewards are immense. However, for more laid-back or inexperienced dog owners, the cons of owning a Dutch Shepherd may outweigh the benefits.
