Understanding the Cons of Owning a Dutch Shepherd
Although the Dutch Shepherd is a remarkably versatile and loyal breed, it is not without its challenges. Bred in the Netherlands as an all-purpose farm dog, this breed thrives in environments that offer physical activity and mental engagement. However, their intelligence and independence can make them a tough fit for certain households. Below, we explore the potential downsides of owning a Dutch Shepherd to help prospective owners make an informed decision.
1. High Energy and Exercise Needs
Dutch Shepherds are extremely energetic dogs. They were developed to work all day herding livestock, guarding farms, and even pulling carts. Consequently, they require ample daily exercise to remain balanced and healthy.
- At least 60–90 minutes of physical activity each day is necessary
- They enjoy structured activities like agility, obedience, or scent work
- Without stimulation, they may become bored and destructive
2. Not Suited for First-Time Dog Owners
Because of their intelligence and independent nature, Dutch Shepherds can be difficult for novice handlers.
- They need consistent, firm, and positive training
- Handlers must be confident and experienced with working breeds
- A lack of leadership can lead to behavioral issues, including dominance or anxiety
3. Strong Herding and Prey Drive
These dogs retain much of their original herding instincts. This can translate to chasing or nipping behaviors.
- They may try to herd people, especially children
- Some individuals exhibit a moderate prey drive, chasing cats or small animals
- Supervision around smaller pets and young kids is essential
4. Potential Behavioral Issues Without Structure
Highly intelligent breeds like the Dutch Shepherd can become bored without a job. They thrive in highly structured households where they receive regular training and tasks.
- Boredom may manifest in excessive barking, digging, or chewing
- They require regular mental stimulation like puzzle toys and problem-solving games
- They may become difficult to manage if left alone for long periods
5. Need for Early and Ongoing Socialization
While they are affectionate with family, Dutch Shepherds can be aloof or reserved with strangers.
- Without early socialization, they may become overly protective or shy
- Proper exposure to a variety of people, animals, and environments is crucial
- Some Dutch Shepherds may react unpredictably in unfamiliar situations
6. Grooming Requirements Differ by Coat Type
This breed comes in three coat varieties: short, long, and rough.
- Short-haired: Needs occasional brushing; daily grooming during shedding seasons
- Long-haired: Requires weekly combing to prevent mats
- Rough-haired: Needs weekly brushing and biannual hand-stripping
While grooming is not especially arduous, it does require consistency and attention, particularly during shedding periods.
7. Health Concerns to Watch For
Although generally healthy, Dutch Shepherds can still be prone to certain genetic disorders.
- Hip and elbow dysplasia
- Progressive Retinal Atrophy (especially in rough-haired types)
- Degenerative myelopathy and inflammatory myopathy
- Von Willebrand disease in long-haired lines
Reputable breeders conduct genetic testing, but potential owners should still be aware of these risks.
8. Not a Low-Maintenance Pet
The Dutch Shepherd is far from a couch potato. They demand quality attention, physical challenges, and mental activities regularly. People looking for a passive or low-energy companion may find this breed overwhelming.
9. Financial and Time Commitment
This breed may also represent a significant investment of time and resources.
- Training and structured activities like canine sports may incur costs
- Feeding high-quality food for an energetic, mid-to-large breed can be expensive
- Health screenings, especially from responsible breeders, may add to adoption costs
Is a Dutch Shepherd the Right Dog for You?
Ultimately, Dutch Shepherds are loyal, intelligent, and athletic dogs that make excellent companions for experienced, active owners. They excel in structured environments that satisfy both mind and body. However, for those who are unprepared for their demands, the cons can quickly outweigh the benefits. Proper training, early socialization, and a strong leadership role are essential to raising a Dutch Shepherd that fits harmoniously into family life.
