Understanding the Downsides of Owning a Dutch Shepherd
The Dutch Shepherd is a remarkable working dog known for its loyalty, intelligence, and adaptability. However, like all breeds, it has its drawbacks that potential owners should carefully consider. Understanding these challenges will help you determine whether this high-energy breed fits your lifestyle.
1. High Exercise Needs
Dutch Shepherds were bred for labor-intensive farm work, which means they possess
exceptionally high energy levels. These dogs require daily vigorous physical and mental stimulation.
- At least 60 to 90 minutes of exercise daily
- Participation in dog sports like agility or obedience training is recommended
- Boredom can lead to destructive behaviors such as chewing or digging
If you cannot commit to regular activity and training, this breed may become frustrated and unruly.
2. Not Ideal for First-Time Owners
Due to their
independent thinking and strong will, Dutch Shepherds are better suited for experienced dog owners.
- They require consistent, confident leadership
- Inexperienced handlers may struggle with the breed’s intense work drive
This breed needs someone skilled in managing high-drive dogs and invested in early, ongoing training.
3. Behavioral Challenges Without Structure
When not given a job or consistent mental challenges, Dutch Shepherds can exhibit unwanted behaviors.
- Excessive barking as territorial or boredom response
- Separation anxiety in under-stimulated individuals
- Potential for dominance without clear boundaries
Structure, routine, and job-based engagement are key to a balanced temperament.
4. Aloofness Toward Strangers
Dutch Shepherds tend to be
reserved or cautious with strangers, which can be beneficial for guarding but challenging socially.
- Early socialization is crucial to prevent reactivity
- May not be suitable in busy households or with frequent visitors
Proper introduction and training can help improve their sociability but instincts may remain.
5. Grooming Demands Based on Coat Type
While none of the coat types are overly difficult, grooming varies among the
three coat varieties:
- Short-haired: occasional brushing; daily during shedding season
- Long-haired: weekly grooming required
- Rough-haired: weekly brushing and twice-yearly hand-stripping
Neglected coats can become matted or uncomfortable, impacting dog health.
6. Health Considerations
Although generally healthy, some
heritable conditions have been observed:
- Hip and elbow dysplasia
- Progressive retinal atrophy (especially in rough-haired)
- Degenerative myelopathy
- Inflammatory myopathy in some bloodlines
- von Willebrand disease in long-haired types
Working with responsible breeders who perform health screenings can minimize these risks.
7. Herding and Prey Drive
Being a herding breed, Dutch Shepherds often exhibit a
strong prey drive and protective behaviors.
- May herd children or small animals if not properly trained
- High alertness can cause reactive behavior
Supervision and structured training are essential to managing instincts.
8. Vocal Nature
These dogs often bark to
alert their family of changes in surroundings.
- While useful for protection, it may become a nuisance in apartments or quiet neighborhoods
Behavioral training can help control excessive alert barking.
Is the Dutch Shepherd Right for You?
The Dutch Shepherd makes a loyal and trainable companion—but only for the right kind of owner. You may be a good match if:
- You have experience with working breeds
- You lead an active lifestyle
- You are willing to invest time in training and grooming
Those seeking low-maintenance or low-energy pets should explore other breeds more suited to that lifestyle.
Conclusion
While Dutch Shepherds are intelligent, agile, and versatile, their
need for physical exertion, mental stimulation, and ongoing training can be demanding. For individuals and families prepared to meet these needs, the Dutch Shepherd can be an incredibly loyal and capable partner. For others, however, the cons may outweigh the benefits. Proper research and match evaluation are essential before bringing one into your home.
